Classic recipes, modern flavor
Round pies, Sicilian, grandma, heroes, pasta, and an 8-ounce burger when the table wants more than pizza.
Our menu
Staten Island · Since 2012
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza
Neighborhood pies, heroes, and burgers at 1250 Hylan Boulevard. Dine in, take it out, or send an order for delivery.
Your event, our trays
Half trays feed 6–9 people and full trays feed 10–15. The same kitchen that runs the counter handles the party.
CateringReady when you are
Order pies, wings, and sides for pickup or delivery. Online ordering lives at order-brooklyn-s-finest-pizzeria.microskyfood.com.
Order nowMore than a slice shop
Since 2012, Brooklyn's Finest has been the weekday pie, the Friday hero, and the tray that shows up at the office. The people who run it live and work in the Staten Island neighborhoods they serve.
The menu covers the classics — pizzas, pastas, salads, and wraps — plus a long list of neighborhood heroes, kid-friendly plates, gluten-free and vegan-friendly options, and 8-ounce brisket-sirloin burgers.
House pies and heroes
Full menuSpecialty large pies
- Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, & Tomatoes Pizza$21.99
- Hot Honey Roni Pizza$21.99
- Chicken Cutlet, Vodka Sauce, & Fresh Mozzarella Pizza$23.99
- Artichoke Pizza$25.99
- Cheesesteak Pizza$23.99
- Veggie Pie$21.99
Neighborhood heroes
- The Coney Island Hero$12.99
- The Sea Gate Hero$15.99
- The Midwood Hero$14.99
- The Gowanus Hero$14.99
- The Bed Stuy Hero$14.99
- New Utrecht Hero$14.99
What guests say
“This is my spot. Love the buffalo cauliflower pizza. Everything is good, staff super friendly and helpful. Seven years, no complaints — they treat me like I'm eating in their home. Best egg creams on the island.”
“I love having Brooklyn's Finest delivered. The food tastes great and the quality is consistent. Hubby must have his veal parm and I opted for a Greek salad with grilled chicken. The cheese pizza is perfect and the baked ziti is worth a try.”
“Brooklyn's Finest Pizza lives up to its name. The food is top-notch, and the owner is down-to-earth and easy to work with. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or ordering for a big event, you won't be disappointed.”